mp on Wed, 31 Oct 2018 20:08:33 +0100 (CET)
|
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]
Re: <nettime> Stallman and property relations // Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)
|
- To: nettime-l@mail.kein.org
- Subject: Re: <nettime> Stallman and property relations // Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)
- From: mp <mp@aktivix.org>
- Date: Wed, 31 Oct 2018 19:06:42 +0000
- Autocrypt: addr=mp@aktivix.org; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFntziIBEADh4gvskTCbmVcojT8jt2ACNU1TGg1WMrg9oSkjDeubEMreWzGfzvdrza9Y uCNglBV4xJTTL00F2rJi+hfQ4Weo9xeMN8ooZmmkcgDWsNA+l+Evidlg4rKOy2Y1dyNrSKlK GMdyW8+a6/2gyE5+5ndY25cUOiJemLOXRSGRKypbFg0HGUiJ9ujPa5okfhK2kSb6LKulEiCp 3DeWhu2MgF8z6sQQ91ksbqacgH6C9oJQKjP9q+cGR5SHFP3Rl5yb3pXJk4GAfuWz8tcmgNuw C9zJjqPvoBshxNK3wjehssQSh8o5fybZOMlpBakStEWN1v1FwAMpbE9p6sodku6XPonAQMa8 mxEWtdsg5ok15G/S8s51LkPpLCYdprFPUVtSSG71xHAqueh1DBPUWZUSMfYB4Yb9r/yqLKFn 0Lkmi+wYi2BRPHLkhCndFoQXj+4vNfi9oRUE6LESvsQTtGxAlX0MqLBHnU/WEZQUTM/ZhC7c NiK+rn0+PtDV7y5k8I1PI8HNoEsiBs7bojuTO+7jbznKAjOy3iHS0+W0z6q4LyiQI9/iR0sB hk3cKQQThIbbVrLAZj3fkxyKEanoqojxcmBgjJvUmmqBoub903zs/ullId1U2VKYB3jKtVeg rz3k+3nt//4tbBIjn+22R/fzpp/ddzqeDrPqEitYdUauFQWygQARAQABzRNtcCA8bXBAYWt0 aXZpeC5vcmc+wsF9BBMBCAAnBQJZ7c4iAhsjBQkJZgGABQsJCAcCBhUICQoLAgQWAgMBAh4B AheAAAoJEClaQxJuh/tHNLcQAJBTDTAimd3EQSKlYmpRyelVqBemQBWFPsCe8KZnMGnBiA3b JrxVJQMW4W4XH6t8F+aZxxS2nLOLRqXgo1CpSuYC6Qx3otfPund4RYSlfdhbZsEwpOVzqv/H lcPVSGbHj4nFT0abL/oSE2hgKynIXK2lX028KOCCXn7KDODN2P0SLqtKZjLrbuKo104d6xkQ sQ+6Nox2iS71J05p/lPMjz7wtyX1Vbd92D26ELOKiKYlU+FA5FZIzquZC/N/dhyxAmQ6BtjF HuRtTaA0C1xJ/Z14sY4ybDTvV2hic59XD7Hsu9+vpEUGAPMK512SyaqeR5LHFsKv37lZy+Gv x98w031w6hK0foo23+zZ3J5L0pqKSVjGlSSrxF0dOEJ7dnIBUcx36eGBg+b9RIwX5Suwo6R5 pcoEsr/Sgx/4IKR9NNNi1GPIM22ZH+iod0cP2QfGmyfkyYe6DVmxH5ISAZO7GDca1A/uOS1P Yv+H75DkhyJalU9Pp80QjkbRc67pDWN9Y4P+qDH8dl2p/joclFUT6fACCxv6RgxqtCWVQI42 Dtk710IqWluBnF9ypv2VSeEgO12cmH723CFuAUzdRTXOmzuiez2LEJI/IvaCskb62ziqYmNn kKZUqHnsQ+ewjp+qLJa944DgiMiTe2NVrqxtunOGGfo0A7SnirHuTd8JSZgezsFNBFntziIB EACukM2vdjIeYyyeyDSrvynTq3PNRAH0rx6rb1f8lSNDiMq5BdZDXZxt+IGFwdUmyfPI0PvL d99/B8xCX1D14/52qqJFnXqvguNRHF26DiDHobQAiiJyFaTGx2XLTlwLvXumR4E3drfqhAAR Y8BUSDHrRdZbPXqaZZPnG5Bmo49APv/gR6wMO20B+Ua4hVTkSbuc2jbjkF+6iBmIkOv4Ry+q wNcD690yoJZElU4aJid0HXVV0q4AfjNoSq5AYc2aZaOwbQgyWnPNAiCKzFwOmBUCKJ4Nzdbo UVk19oZ3pNcXXgYsIpx3tmuPmuwcWzqS10wApwu4eA8JJovRKLZ1KFdvekbl1xXY4FAzI6Fj KrP3HaBcEq/Q7gQKwy765GfOkev1ej/gS+9SgRJit4qGDqzckZf5xO2HgiAg2n63NXLWTXk8 4ukQ7cVNoWGYt1vQ6qG34CDybvDpqWc4N2qzHuzvtbuDJwWCrh/Xg1a7DwJ0ObVF+KEHuiHX Jdq9Fu1XOtK28OlpOpUmazHjedE4lSrIBToUt9YbH7Te4GND4zoD4skNFJ0jTEd0/NdkElmh sMIf4BP1QhOn7R21avUGL6UvOAbFTou3Cgsb+v9jEpa8XM008c5nRq2s3LxrCjPdhlShH4dK FTEV4xtvc0N3/hwdhMCicSVeX2gc7+Uw57b5vQARAQABwsFlBBgBCAAPBQJZ7c4iAhsMBQkJ ZgGAAAoJEClaQxJuh/tHcooP/1ZXmt/XpPk55HSq4OG2/kPdNJdcxszrAGMCKu3Lgjt/PryL shza5EAgIHhdiuWoTQ+1Wie6lZU0qOuf/eqMqPQScUimIbR50WWliabBb2WQrmMjEDRbQhKu V4DlmzkbfhPZksWYgUSjfNRn9mh5zhX41XEJ6wgVxRrgi74cY2JTjFKRClsCAAkKryqU4ABE URlpBo9Pky7EKJwvyNnbmfThLMNThRA3tvC+GHPYLwtBQ5GoyII77vIpYS3J0t2KUTl572jT rorsk6zuFECguRRi0BgHTLWITnIJBgpnp5a661JAZsHtoR5O8Z7iSrSpeI4NIuiQSxvdjVHs 25Wm2HIrB1No8SNOAsGSGamap7oZDskaKWNFRHQZsFkaeuhn3CuQ4maRdmbetblfMGYpwH9D pWeKmkN+ADJdosJG5OrTXRbIYImzeQ/3BCBhKiKY2Kcq9SlRwlWztpLsiRTLJD8yRYDHJ1M6 It2K6cFk0BQp0lRzxMuyP1QOggkk5UuX68hkjwNub+kFUIp//D4fzIKbgrrnpnN2RYE1ULXc Bi+K9fBfbQY9UHDS6Eig+vJV807EnU4L50+e9GWqSwmqRTe83KDN7ySwmCIuAy4TU6Zd9FN4 weUDhxURKeUYJL+fIRHv4OjpQ/Y0JZ0qyj0sP4u7Gdg2Tiqxr3W5flsT7jJB
- In-reply-to: <582bda95-7342-0ad7-7583-cecd46eaf8c2@irmielin.org>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <CALCqc1AjHO3ESndU7q=i2oPoV9hiP0S6KvM=+fvXDQ-_OW8mKw@mail.gmail.com> <CADCyihQOCWKyvKvuQEw7pzVBKyTD3b7EEbG4Dz9-KNcG5Kh2VA@mail.gmail.com> <79ffb9bd-80e4-462a-ac7f-21f61aa27cd0@posteo.net> <1ef4946b-50eb-2e4b-d9ec-8b0006e7cdfa@modspil.dk> <CADCyihQT_gA_x5b0TjRicbyuQpUFdzmQU3dtHNx2y=iWAUe13w@mail.gmail.com> <2941126f-0c13-c4a4-f9b6-269e318628e4@modspil.dk> <dd162190-6c77-b454-a1cf-35b0bde4d386@opentechsummit.net> <582bda95-7342-0ad7-7583-cecd46eaf8c2@irmielin.org>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.2.1
On 31/10/2018 15:43, Francis Hunger wrote:
> Hi everybody,
>
> I was a bit disappointed, that this kind of 'weak' Stallman interview
> was published in the New Left Review. 'Weak' insofar as I can't see much
> 'leftist' in it.
In that context it might be worth noting that 'rms' is not some sort of
anti-capitalist or even much of a lefty: he is probably better described
as a liberal rights oriented advocate.
In an email exchange that counted 108 emails about property relations,
he made it very clear that he is entirely supportive of exclusive,
private property in the means of production - i.e. wants to keep things
as they are under capitalism. He just wants an exception for software
that, somehow, idiosyncratically, should be treated as rights and
policy, not property (which is not a very good argument).
happy property hacking [not!]
m
# distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
# <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
# collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
# more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
# archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime@kein.org
# @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject: